Bay Shore Homes under $1.5 million

Welcome to Bay Shore, New York—a charming waterfront community nestled in the heart of Suffolk County. Known for its picturesque views of the Great South Bay, Bay Shore combines the tranquility of suburban living with the vibrancy of coastal life. With its rich history and a diverse array of recreational opportunities, this town is perfect for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

Bay Shore boasts a delightful mix of amenities, including boutique shops, delectable dining options, and lush parks, making it an ideal place to call home. The town’s convenient location offers easy access to the Long Island Rail Road, providing a seamless commute to New York City. For outdoor enthusiasts, the nearby beaches, marinas, and nature preserves present endless opportunities for adventure, from boating to hiking.

When it comes to housing, Bay Shore is particularly appealing for those seeking homes under $1.5 million. The real estate market here features a variety of options, ranging from charming single-family homes to modern townhouses, all set against the backdrop of stunning bay views. Many properties come with spacious yards, perfect for entertaining or relaxing in the sun.

Whether you’re drawn to the area's natural beauty, vibrant community spirit, or the prospect of owning a beautiful home, Bay Shore offers a unique blend of coastal charm and suburban convenience. Explore your options today and discover why Bay Shore might just be the perfect place for you to settle down and create lasting memories.

Newest Bay Shore Homes under $1.5 million

$779,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1062234 MLS

Lovingly maintained by the same owner for over 50 years, this charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bath split-level is located in the desirable West Bay Shore area, just blocks from Brightwaters Village. Situated on a beautiful .34-acre park-like property, this home offers plenty of space, privacy, and endless possibilities. Updates completed in 2017 include the roof, siding, windows, and bathroom. Additional features include central air conditioning, an attached garage, oil heat, and natural gas cooking. Natural gas is already in the home, offering the potential for conversion from oil heat. Public sewers—no septic system! A wonderful opportunity to make this well-cared-for home your own in a sought-after location.

991 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore

$1,050,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1062487 MLS

Ability to expand to 1980 sq ft

84 Oak Walk, Bay Shore

$699,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1062312 MLS

Welcome home to this inviting 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch offering comfortable living and plenty of room to spread out! Beautiful hardwood floors add warmth and character throughout the main living areas. Enjoy a cozy den featuring an electric flame fireplace, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. The full finished basement offers additional versatile living space with room for extended family, guests, recreation, or a home office. Step outside to a spacious, fully fenced yard, ideal for outdoor gatherings, gardening, or simply enjoying the outdoors. An inviting front porch adds to the home's charm and provides the perfect spot to unwind. Additional highlights include a new stainless steel boiler and a propane gas generator for added convenience and peace of mind. With its flexible layout, generous indoor and outdoor spaces, and desirable features, this ranch has so much to offer. Don't miss the opportunity to make it your own! Photos were enhanced for lighting and removal of personal property and minor cosmetic repairs.

1073 Oakneck Road, Bay Shore

$699,900

2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1059661 MLS

Sun-Filled End Unit in Sought-After Mystic Pines (55+). This move-in ready home checks every box. The prime location offers views of the pool and park like grounds, and the back deck’s retractable awning makes outdoor living effortless. Inside, hardwood and laminate flooring flows throughout for easy care, complemented by LED high-hats. Both bedrooms feature en suite baths and walk-in closets, and second-floor laundry (with newer washer/dryer) adds everyday convenience. The updated kitchen shines with stainless appliances and granite counters. A full basement with egress window offers flexible bonus space, while the one-car garage includes a storage loft. A private elevator provides effortless access to every level. Enjoy resort-style amenities including a pool, clubhouse, and gym — all close to shopping, beaches, and parks!

30 Torrey Pine Lane, Bay Shore

$549,900

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061307 MLS

Welcome to this lovely home filled with space, character, and more than 40 years of cherished memories. This inviting 5-bedroom, 2-bath expanded Cape sits on a expansive 0.9-acre parcel, offering room to grow, relax, and create something uniquely your own. This home features a garage to living space conversion, along with 18.5' x 21’ addition providing exciting potential for a home office, guest space, or accessory apartment (with proper permits.) A full basement with outside entrance also adds valuable storage and flexibility. Improvements include, a new heating system in 2014 when the home was converted to natural gas and 150 amp electric. All major appliances; dishwasher, range, refrigerator, washer and dryer were replaced within the last 3-5 years. The interior has been freshly painted, and many of the interior doors have been replaced to give the new owner a blank canvas to bring their vision to life. Enjoy morning coffee on the charming wraparound front porch or gather with friends on the covered rear patio. With nearly an acre of property to enjoy, the possibilities are limited only by your imagination. Conveniently located between the Ronkonkoma and Babylon branches of the LIRR and less than a mile from the Southern State and Sagtikos Parkways, this home offers a peaceful setting with commuter-friendly access. After more than four decades with one family, it is ready to welcome its next chapter and new owners who are ready to make it their own.

1041 Joselson Avenue, Bay Shore

$599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1062130 MLS

Welcome to Bay Shore! Don’t miss this beautifully redone Cape Cod offering 4 bedrooms and 1 full bath! With its refreshed interior and oil heat, this home is ready for its next chapter. Whether you’re looking for your first home or a place to make new memories, this is an opportunity you won’t want to miss! Come take a look and make this home YOURS!

1801 Stein Drive, Bay Shore

$899,998

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1048854 MLS

Charming and spacious ranch located South of Montauk in one of Bay Shores most charming areas. Open floor plan with stone fireplace, wood floors and a bright airy floor plan.

87 Bayway Avenue, Bay Shore

$624,999

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1061716 MLS

Welcome home to this beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch, thoughtfully updated in 2018 from top to bottom. The extensive renovations include new doors, Andersen windows, roof, siding, HVAC system, and radiant heated floors, providing comfort and peace of mind. The inviting kitchen is a true standout, featuring an oversized quartz island that serves as the perfect centerpiece for meal preparation, casual dining, and entertaining. The vaulted ceilings enhance the home's open, airy feel, while ample storage ensures plenty of room to keep everything organized and in its place. The primary bedroom with private ensuite is located on the north side of the house and the other two guest bedrooms on the south side of the house, there is plenty of privacy for all. Step outside to enjoy the composite front deck, an ideal spot to relax and unwind. Enjoy relaxing nights in the tranquil backyard around the store fire pit. There is additional storage in the shed outside. With major updates already completed and thoughtful features throughout, this exceptional home offers the ease of turnkey living without the hassle of renovations. This move-in-ready home offers the perfect blend of style, comfort, and functionality. Simply unpack and enjoy all this beautifully updated ranch has to offer!

1435 Brooklyn Boulevard, Bay Shore

$630,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1053596 MLS

Welcome to 1053 Martinstein Avenue, Bay Shore, a charming Cape Cod offering space, comfort, and plenty of possibilities! This inviting home features 4 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms, providing a versatile layout with room for everyone. Step inside to a welcoming eat-in kitchen and comfortable living spaces enhanced by a combination of tile and laminate flooring. The full basement provides valuable additional space for storage, recreation, a home office, or future customization. Enjoy the convenience of oil heating, a private driveway, and a fully fenced yard. Step outside to the patio/deck, creating a wonderful setting for outdoor gatherings, relaxing, and enjoying time with family and friends. Conveniently located near schools, shopping, and public transportation, this home offers easy access to everyday amenities and commuting options. With its spacious layout, flexible basement, private outdoor space, and convenient location, 1053 Martinstein Avenue is a wonderful opportunity to make this beautiful Bay Shore Cape Cod your next home!

1053 Martinstein Avenue, Bay Shore

$749,999

6 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1059764 MLS

6 Bedrooms, Room for Everyone, Easy NYC Commute! This spacious, move-in ready Bay Shore Colonial has 6 bedrooms and 2 full baths, with the flexible layout multi-generational living calls for. An elegant tray ceiling sets off the living room. Recessed lighting, parquet wood floors, and custom moldings run throughout the home. The primary suite has its own tray ceiling, a walk-in closet, and an en-suite bath with a double vanity, a clawfoot soaking tub, and a separate shower. Comfort and savings come standard with 2-zone central air and solar panels for lower energy bills. The home is in excellent condition and ready for you. You're minutes from the Bay Shore LIRR station for an easy ride into New York City. Sunrise Highway and the Southern State Parkway are close by, along with downtown Bay Shore's shops and dining, the marina, and the Fire Island ferries. Space like this in a prime South Shore location won't last.

46 Garden City Street, Bay Shore

$799,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1005955 MLS

Don't miss this single-family home located at 1624 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore. Situated on a spacious lot, this property offers great potential and is conveniently located near shopping, transportation, schools, and major roadways. Whether you're searching for your next home or an investment opportunity, this property is definitely worth seeing

1624 E 3rd Avenue, Bay Shore

$305,000

1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1060824 MLS

Please be advised that, as per the seller/sponsor’s request, all offers must be pre-approved by the seller’s preferred lender to provide the seller with additional comfort regarding the buyer’s ability to obtain financing. This fully renovated one-bedroom, second-floor unit features a new kitchen, new appliances, new bathroom, new heating and air-conditioning system, new lighting, fresh paint, new doors and moldings, and new carpeting. Heat and water are included in the monthly maintenance, with the owner responsible only for electricity and cable. The unit consists of 870 shares, with a monthly maintenance of $994.77.

44 Pinebrook Place Unit #44, Bay Shore

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.