Bay Shore Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bay Shore, New York – a charming gem nestled in the heart of Suffolk County! This vibrant coastal community offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban convenience, making it an ideal place to call home. With its picturesque waterfront, thriving local culture, and easy access to the bustling city life of New York City, Bay Shore is a haven for those seeking both relaxation and excitement.

Bay Shore boasts a rich history, reflected in its beautifully preserved architecture and bustling downtown area. Enjoy leisurely strolls along the scenic Great South Bay, where you can take in stunning sunsets or indulge in a variety of water activities. The town is also home to a diverse array of restaurants, shops, and parks, creating a welcoming atmosphere for residents and visitors alike.

For those considering a move, Bay Shore offers a wide selection of homes for sale that cater to various lifestyles and budgets. From charming single-family homes with spacious yards to modern condos with breathtaking bay views, there’s something for everyone. The real estate market here is vibrant, with opportunities for first-time homebuyers, families, and retirees alike.

In addition to its beautiful homes, Bay Shore is served by excellent schools and convenient public transportation options, making it easy to commute to nearby cities. Whether you’re drawn to the area’s natural beauty, community spirit, or the promise of a fulfilling lifestyle, Bay Shore is ready to welcome you home. Discover your dream property today and experience all the charm this delightful town has to offer!

Newest Bay Shore Homes for Sale

$619,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1049627 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully renovated 4-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offering comfortable one-level living. This move-in-ready home features updated finishes throughout, a spacious and functional layout, and plenty of room for everyday living and entertaining. A detached garage provides additional storage and parking. Conveniently located with easy access to major roadways, shopping, dining, and everyday amenities, this home combines modern updates with an ideal location.

1340 Manor Lane, Bay Shore

$749,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048658 MLS

Looking for a true "move in ready" Hi-Ranch in the heart of Bayshore in Islip School District in close proximity to all of the amenities you could wish for including but not limited to; public transportation, restaurants, parks, marinas and much much more? Ok great! Welcome to this beautifully updated 1,750 sq. ft. home offering a flexible layout and an abundance of recent improvements! The main level features an inviting open-concept living room and kitchen equipped with gas cooking and new stainless steel appliances, high ceilings, wainscoting, an updated full bathroom and two bedrooms. The lower level offers additional versatile living space with a two separate entrances offering immense privacy and the potential for extended family or rental income with proper permits. Featuring a one-bedroom layout with a kitchen and living room combination and a full bathroom with an outside entrance. There is also an additional studio-style space with its own separate entrance, offering the potential for a fourth bedroom, guest space, home office, or additional living area and another full bathroom. The home includes a dedicated laundry room with new tile and a stackable washer and dryer, and utilities. Recent updates include a newer roof, new forced-hot-air heating system, new mini-split AC system, new deck, fresh interior and exterior paint, new foyer tile, and refinished wood floors. With 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, and multiple flexible living spaces, this home offers exceptional versatility and plenty of room to make it your own! Enjoy the curb appeal and blank canvass of a yard equipped with in-ground sprinklers being the "cherry on top" of this beautiful listing! Do not miss 1527 St Louis Avenue, Bayshore! LOW TAXES W/ BASIC STAR (Islip School District).

1527 Saint Louis Avenue, Bay Shore

$520,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1025795 MLS

Welcome to this 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom Ranch with 1,710 square feet of one level living. It offers hardwood floors an updated kitchen with quartz counters and stainless appliances. The primary suite features its own private full bathroom, and two additional spacious bedrooms, a dedicated laundry room with plenty of storage, updated vinyl siding and windows (2023) and an attached garage with an electric opener. Outside enjoy a fully fenced backyard with in ground sprinkler system and covered front porch. This home is move in ready!

15 Center Avenue, Bay Shore

$680,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1047846 MLS

Move in ready home in Bay Shore with custom upgrades galore! Kept in the family since it was built, this spacious 5-bedroom, 3-bathroom hi-ranch also offers a partial basement to make your own. The upper level features 4 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, including a primary ensuite, plus a bright family room. Downstairs offers a living room with maple hardwood flooring, two flexible office/den spaces, an updated kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and a beautiful dining room. Additional updates include vinyl siding with shake accents on the front, a top-of-the-line Roth oil tank, and a generator-ready hookup for added convenience. The roof and driveway seal, were also completed within approx. the last ten years. Outside, enjoy your own private oasis lined with trees for added privacy, a lush well-maintained vegetable garden, in-ground sprinklers, and newer fencing. Centrally located near shopping centers and a local brewery, this home is just minutes from major highways, major beaches, and Bay Shore's Main Street!

35 Jensen Road, Bay Shore

$499,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 1047632 MLS

Welcome home to this charming Bay Shore ranch, where exceptional comfort meets limitless potential! The main living quarters feature an eat-in kitchen, entertainment space, two comfortable bedrooms, including a large bedroom featuring a sliding glass door that opens directly onto a beautiful composite deck—perfect for your morning coffee or seamless indoor-outdoor living, and a well-appointed full bathroom centrally services the home. The interior footprint is extended by incredible bonus spaces, including a full basement—perfect for a recreation room, home gym, or workshop—and a full attic that provides massive, convenient storage to keep your living areas flawlessly organized. Step outside to find the true crown jewel of the property: an impressively large, sprawling lot dotted with mature trees that offer a private backyard oasis. With an abundance of open space, it provides a rare canvas with tremendous room for expansion or a spectacular outdoor entertainment design. Nestled on a peaceful residential street with public water and easy access to local dining, shopping, and transit, this property is an absolute must-see opportunity waiting for your personal touch!

25 W Oakdale Street, Bay Shore

$689,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1048032 MLS

Welcome Home! step into this beautifully updated residence where comfort meets style, it offers 4Br, 3Bth a full finished basement with outside separate entrance, this property is conveniently located close to all shopping and major highways, Don't miss this opportunity, New Cesspool, windows, roof, siding, front entrance too much to list many updates a must see!!!

1085 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore

$799,999

5 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1045316 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully maintained 5-bedroom, 2-bath home, lovingly cared for by the same owners for many, many years! This spacious and inviting property offers a wonderful combination of charm, comfort, and versatility, with part of the home currently utilized as an Airbnb, providing an excellent opportunity for additional income potential. Inside, you’ll find beautiful wood floors, crown molding, a cozy fireplace, central air, gas heat, and a bright, inviting sunroom perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or relaxing at the end of the day. The bedrooms are generously sized and the primary accommodates king-size furniture, while the large 'granny' attic offers abundant storage. Step outside to an amazing entertaining yard featuring a sparkling inground pool, spacious deck, and plenty of room for gatherings and summer fun. The large driveway provides ample parking, complemented by a garage for additional storage and convenience. Cedar-impression vinyl siding adds attractive curb appeal with easy maintenance. Ideally located less than a mile from Main Street and the railroad station, and close to the Fire Island ferries, hospitals, shopping, dining, and transportation. Whether you’re looking for a spacious home, an entertaining oasis, or a property with income-producing potential, this well-loved home offers it all!

73 Maple Avenue, Bay Shore

$500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1047581 MLS

Investor Delight! Opportunity knocks! 3 bedroom 2 bath Ranch with full finished basement OSE. Needs a lot of work! Selling As-Is.. Tear down-New Build? Fix N Flip? Or Maybe a Second Floor Addition? Will not approve for an FHA Loan. Large lot sits on .31 acres. Great Location!! -4 mins from Deer Park Tanger Outlets -2 mins from Heartland Golf Park -7 mins from Suffolk Community College -8-9 mins from Costco & Walmart -Right off of the Sagtikos State Parkway

1743 N Thompson Drive, Bay Shore

$829,000

6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1047326 MLS

Welcome to this beautifully renovated 6-bedroom, 3-bathroom home in Bay Shore! Featuring brand-new finishes, new tile, updated appliances, and air-conditioning systems, this move-in-ready home offers modern comfort and style. Enjoy excellent Mother-Daughter potential, a private driveway, a two-car garage, and a spacious lot just shy of half an acre, with a recreational backyard perfect for entertaining, relaxation, and family activities. Conveniently located near major highways, shopping, schools, and transportation. A truly turnkey home with space and versatility—don’t miss this opportunity!

529 Spur Drive N, Bay Shore

$649,950

6 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 1045756 MLS

Colonial style home with huge ancillary structure on a large parcel with exceptional potential. This property is centrally located providing close proximity to local amenities and is a great opportunity.

54 Oneill Avenue, Bay Shore

$649,990

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1047137 MLS

Welcome to this spacious Ranch, featuring 3 bedrooms, 3 bathroom and more with a large back yard, full basement with separate entrance. Perfect for Mother and Daughter

73 Michigan Avenue, Bay Shore

$3,999,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 1032772 MLS

SPECTACULAR 2.75-ACRE WATERFRONT CONTEMPORARY ESTATE A truly rare opportunity to own an extraordinary privately gated 3,800 sq. ft. waterfront estate set on 2.75 breathtaking acres with over 1,000 feet of bulkhead and spectacular water views. Step through the grand double glass doors into a stunning open-concept interior featuring soaring windows, beautiful ceramic flooring, and a magnificent chandelier overlooking the water. The home offers 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a second-floor loft, dining room, living room with fireplace, and a 3-car garage.The fabulous chef’s kitchen features custom wood cabinetry, a large granite island, and professional Wolf and Verona stainless-steel appliances. The luxurious primary en-suite offers a spa bath, walk-in closet, glass doors with balcony and deck with bay views, elevator access, along with a convenient second-floor laundry room. The waterfront lifestyle is truly exceptional, offering over 1,000 feet of bulkhead, a large boat slip accommodating two 65-foot yachts, a boat ramp, and a dedicated cut-out for multiple jet skis. A spacious boathouse and waterfront gazebo provide the perfect setting for enjoying the water, while a beautiful patio and pergola create an ideal space for outdoor entertaining and relaxation. Take in breathtaking sunsets with picturesque views of the Robert Moses Bridge. Additional amenities include a full-house generator, 27-zone sprinkler system, and an on-demand tankless hot water heater. Perfectly positioned approximately 60 minutes by LIRR to NYC for world-class dining, entertainment and shows, and approximately 60 minutes to the Hamptons and its renowned wineries. From your own home or the nearby local ferries, enjoy a quick 20 minute ride to Fire Island's Ocean Beach and other sought after destinations, where you can spend the day exploring charming shops, enjoying waterfront dining and live music, or relaxing on the beautiful white sand beaches. It's the perfect blend of waterfront living, convenience, and the quintessential Fire Island lifestyle. Conveniently located near shopping, transportation and everyday amenities. A magnificent waterfront estate. An extraordinary lifestyle. A rare opportunity. Call today for your private showing.

170 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.